Sigh. Here’s my commute, written up in today’s “I’m a commuter, get me out of here!” feature in G2…

“Passengers often can’t get on trains northbound from south London in the mornings or southbound from Blackfriars station in the evening. They thump on the windows and yell at squashed up people inside to squash up more. Passengers say First Capital Connect has cut some of the peak-hour trains from eight carriages to four, making the trains even more packed.

[...]

First Capital Connect blames the Department for Transport for drawing up the franchise badly and claims it is not allowed, under the terms of the franchise, to buy more rolling stock. The DfT acknowledges it gave the franchise to FCC because it offered good value for money to taxpayers, not necessarily the best service for customers. It is clear that the system, by selling to the highest bidder, gives little incentive to a train operator to lease more rolling stock - quite the contrary, as it wants to maximise profit.”

Meanwhile, in Scotland…

“If you are strap-hanging on train lines in England and value the remains of your sanity, look away now. It will do you no good to read about the record 88% satisfaction rates that Scottish rail commuters report, nor the £1.9bn, seven-year programme to introduce extra carriages, longer platforms and new rail lines across Scotland, or that train operators rarely breach their promise that no one should stand for more than 10 minutes. Even a recent BBC Radio Scotland phone-in on commuting struggled to find hair-raising stories. In fact, several callers bandied words such as “excellent” and “very comfortable”.


COMMENTS / 4 COMMENTS

I take First Capital Connect (”Thameslink”) north from Kings Cross and it’s very much the same - almost no standing room on many trains, never any seats, trains appearing with shorter configurations than it seems they used to have, delays are frequent, etc etc.

Despite all that, I reckon you’re still more likely to freeze to death on a platform in Scotland than you are in London. ;-)

Robin Hamman thought this on Feb 06 07 at 10:16 am

I did about 55,000 miles on public transport last year, with more miles this year probably. I only needed a taxi service twice, despite traveling to every Local Authority in Scotland, even those far, far away ones. What makes the Scottish system so good is a) it all tends to run on time and b)travelinescotland.com tells you the quickest route to take each time. Because of the first the second is actually worth its salt.

Ewan McIntosh thought this on Feb 06 07 at 10:28 am

Ewan - I refrained from saying this in the post itself, because I only sound bitter, but since you’re rubbing it in I can’t resist saying this in the comments: [bitterlondoner] that’s our tax money you people are spending up there on your perfect trains and functioning NHS! [/bitterlondoner]

Neil Mc thought this on Feb 06 07 at 4:48 pm

Let’s not get controversial and get started on “Scotland’s” Oil!!

An Honest Man thought this on Feb 06 07 at 8:11 pm

SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated. I'll delete unpleasantness. Email me if you spot a comment that crosses the line.

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Return to Top