I’m not sure what left me more surprised from this story in today’s Guardian on the health of Irish and Scots living in England and Wales: the fact that us expats appear to be dropping like flies, or the fact that we’re now being described as an "ethnic minority group". What sets us apart from the majority - congenitally high cholesterol?
"Irish and Scottish
migrants to England and Wales are more likely to die early from a host
of causes than those from other ethnic minority groups, public health
watchdogs say today.Mortality
rates are worse than those in communities more recognised for poor
health such as Bangladeshis and Pakistanis, according to a report
likely to prompt new questions about ‘hidden’ public health problems."
Suicide rates are also 53-75% higher among our jolly little community. Also - a curious theory proposed and dismissed in one paragraph:
"Laurence Gruer, director
of public health science at NHS Scotland, said: "We are constantly
asking ourselves why Scotland’s health particularly is so bad … one
idea put forward is that Scots who emigrate may be the healthy ones,
leaving behind a residue of the weak and infirm. This finding may
contradict that."
No reasons are offered for the findings - but I’m sure it’ll make a great topic of conversation tonight when the boys and I meet up over a fried pizza supper and a few jars.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « Finding a podcast is hard to do
- » London tonight
- BROWSE / IN Food and Drink Scotland
- « Seduced by the bright lights, again
- » A proud history, an uncertain future
COMMENTS / 3 COMMENTS
Chris thought this on Oct 26 05 at 12:08 amIs it the suggestion that it’s *only* the escapees who die in droves, while the stay-at-homes live to a ripe old age in the celtic fringes? Maybe you miss the rain, or the midges … all these little things which make life worth living.
Bourgeois Wife thought this on Oct 26 05 at 10:04 pmHealthy Scots emigrate, leaving the weak and infirm at home. I like it…
jamie milne thought this on Oct 29 05 at 10:23 amI would guess that a lot of Scots and Irish emigres are manual workers, who are more likely to smoke tabs and drink excessively, ergo the higher death rate. Oh, and journalists as well, obviously :-/
A further explanation may be the relatively poor availability in England of the Scots equivalent of Kryptonite - Irn Bru.
SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated. I'll delete unpleasantness. Email me if you spot a comment that crosses the line.











Your comments